Arbitration and Dispute Resolution in Turkey: Courts, Mediation, International Arbitration and Enforcement

Written by: Emre Can Sepetçi, Attorney at LawUpdated: 13 min read

In short

In Turkey, commercial disputes are heard by the commercial courts of first instance, and for commercial claims for a sum of money, applying to a mediator before filing suit is a mandatory precondition (TTK Art. 5/A). Arbitration with a foreign element seated in Turkey is governed by International Arbitration Law No. 4686; the only remedy against the award is an annulment action brought within 30 days before the regional court of appeal. Awards rendered abroad are enforced by Turkish courts under the New York Convention and Articles 60-62 of Law No. 5718 (MÖHUK).

How can a foreign investor resolve disputes in Turkey?

A foreign investor has three main options: state courts, mediation and arbitration. Article 3(e) of Foreign Direct Investment Law No. 4875 expressly provides that disputes arising from investment agreements may be referred, in addition to the competent local courts, to national or international arbitration or other dispute resolution methods, provided that the parties agree and the conditions of the legislation are met. In practice, a foreign-owned company can decide by contract where and before whom its disputes will be resolved.

That choice is usually made when the contract is signed and is hard to change later. The arbitration clause, the governing law and the jurisdiction clause should therefore be considered together when drafting the documents for company formation, shareholders' agreements, supply and distribution contracts. For the general investment framework, see the Foreign Direct Investment Law guide.

How do Turkish courts handle commercial disputes?

Commercial disputes are, as a rule, heard by the commercial courts of first instance (asliye ticaret mahkemesi). Under Article 5 of Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 (TTK), unless otherwise provided, all commercial cases and non-contentious commercial matters fall within the jurisdiction of the commercial court of first instance, regardless of the value or amount in dispute. Where there is no commercial court, the civil court of first instance hears these cases.

Civil justice in Turkey has three tiers:

  1. Courts of first instance (commercial, civil, etc.) examine the merits and render judgment.
  2. Regional courts of appeal (bölge adliye mahkemesi) review appeals (istinaf) and may re-examine both the facts and the law.
  3. The Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) hears appeals on points of law (temyiz).

Proceedings are conducted in Turkish, and documents in other languages require sworn translation. Including appeals, it can take a long time for a judgment to become final. Duration and language are among the main reasons why arbitration is frequently chosen in international contracts.

Is mediation mandatory in commercial disputes?

Yes, for certain commercial claims. Under TTK Article 5/A, in commercial cases concerning receivables, compensation, annulment of objection to enforcement, negative declaratory actions and restitution claims for a sum of money, applying to a mediator before filing suit is a mandatory procedural precondition. The mediator must conclude the process within six weeks of appointment; this period may be extended by up to two weeks where necessary.

The procedure is set out in Article 18/A of Law No. 6325 on Mediation in Civil Disputes:

  • If a suit is filed without prior mediation, it is dismissed on procedural grounds (Art. 18/A(2)).
  • From the application to the mediation office until the final minutes are drawn up, limitation periods are suspended and time-bar periods do not run (Art. 18/A(15)).
  • A party that fails to attend the first meeting without a valid excuse may bear half of the litigation costs even if it later wins the case (Art. 18/A(11)).
  • Where an arbitration agreement exists, the provisions on mandatory mediation do not apply (Art. 18/A(18)).

If mediation ends in settlement, in commercial disputes a settlement agreement signed jointly by the parties' lawyers and the mediator is treated as equivalent to a court judgment (ilam niteliğinde belge) without the need for an enforceability annotation (Art. 18(4)). This means it can be enforced directly.

When does Turkey's International Arbitration Law apply?

International Arbitration Law No. 4686 applies to disputes involving a foreign element where the seat of arbitration is Turkey, or where the parties or the arbitral tribunal have chosen to apply the Law (Art. 1(2)). Articles 5 (arbitration objection before courts) and 6 (interim injunctions and attachments) apply even when the seat is outside Turkey (Art. 1(3)).

Under Article 2, a dispute has a foreign element if any one of the following applies:

  1. The parties to the arbitration agreement have their domicile, habitual residence or place of business in different states;
  2. The parties' domicile, habitual residence or place of business is in a state other than the seat of arbitration, or other than the place where a substantial part of the main contract is to be performed or with which the dispute is most closely connected;
  3. At least one shareholder of a company party to the main contract has brought in foreign capital under the foreign investment legislation, or loan and/or security agreements must be concluded to obtain capital from abroad for the performance of the contract;
  4. The main contract or legal relationship involves the movement of capital or goods from one country to another.

The third ground is particularly relevant for foreign investors: even a contract between two Turkish companies may qualify as international if a foreign shareholder of one of them has brought in foreign capital.

The Law does not apply to disputes concerning rights in rem over immovable property located in Turkey or to disputes not subject to the parties' free disposal (Art. 1(4)). Arbitrations seated in Turkey without a foreign element are governed by the domestic arbitration rules in Articles 407 to 444 of Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 (HMK) (HMK Art. 407); the same arbitrability limit appears in HMK Art. 408.

How do you draft a valid arbitration agreement?

The arbitration agreement must be in writing (Law No. 4686, Art. 4(2)). The written form is satisfied by a document signed by the parties, by an exchange of letters, faxes or other means of communication, or by electronic means. It is also satisfied where the claimant asserts a written arbitration agreement in its statement of claim and the respondent does not object in its statement of defence. A reference to a document containing an arbitration clause, made so as to incorporate it into the contract, is also valid.

In practice, a well-drafted clause should state clearly:

  • Institution or rules: the Istanbul Arbitration Centre (ISTAC), the ICC International Court of Arbitration, or ad hoc arbitration;
  • Seat: choosing Turkey as the seat triggers Law No. 4686 and the supportive and supervisory powers of the Turkish courts;
  • Number of arbitrators: it must be odd; failing agreement, three arbitrators are appointed (Art. 7(A));
  • Language: Turkish or an official language of a state recognised by the Republic of Turkey (Art. 10(C));
  • Law applicable to the merits: failing a choice, the tribunal applies the substantive law of the state with which the dispute is most closely connected (Art. 12(C)).

The arbitration clause is separable from the main contract: an objection that the main contract is invalid cannot be raised against the arbitration agreement (Art. 4(4)), and the tribunal may rule on its own jurisdiction (Art. 7(H)). Unless the parties agree otherwise, the tribunal must render its award on the merits within one year of the appointment of a sole arbitrator or of the minutes of the tribunal's first meeting (Art. 10(B)). In arbitral proceedings the parties may also be represented by foreign individuals or legal entities (Art. 8(B)).

If one party brings court proceedings despite an arbitration agreement, the other may raise an arbitration objection; if upheld, the court dismisses the case on procedural grounds (Art. 5). Requesting an interim injunction or attachment from a court before or during the arbitration does not breach the arbitration agreement (Art. 6).

How do you choose between ISTAC and the ICC?

The Istanbul Arbitration Centre (ISTAC) was established by Istanbul Arbitration Centre Law No. 6570 (Official Gazette 29 November 2014). The Law aims to enable disputes, including those with a foreign element, to be resolved through arbitration or alternative dispute resolution methods (Art. 1). ISTAC is often chosen for disputes closely connected with Turkey, governed by Turkish law or expected to be enforced in Turkey.

The ICC International Court of Arbitration administers institutional rules widely used in international trade and is often preferred where the parties are based in different countries and want a neutral institution. Whichever institution is chosen, if the seat is in Turkey the remedy against the award is governed by Law No. 4686; if the seat is abroad, the award must go through enforcement (exequatur) proceedings to be executed in Turkey.

Relevant criteria include the parties' nationalities and expectations of neutrality, the likely size of the dispute and cost, the language of the arbitration, the pool of arbitrators and the country where the award will be enforced.

Can an arbitral award rendered in Turkey be challenged?

The only remedy against an arbitral award is an annulment action (Law No. 4686, Art. 15(A)). It is brought before the regional court of appeal having territorial jurisdiction over the place of the court competent under Article 3, and is heard on a priority and expedited basis. The time limit is 30 days from notification of the award (or of the decision on correction, interpretation or an additional award). In international arbitration, filing an annulment action automatically stays enforcement of the award.

The grounds are limited. The applicant must prove incapacity of a party or invalidity of the arbitration agreement, failure to follow the agreed or statutory procedure for appointing the tribunal, failure to render the award within the arbitration period, an unlawful decision by the tribunal that it has or lacks jurisdiction, a decision on matters outside the arbitration agreement or excess of authority, a procedural irregularity affecting the merits, or breach of the principle of equal treatment. In addition, the regional court of appeal annuls the award of its own motion if it finds that the dispute is not arbitrable under Turkish law or that the award is contrary to public policy.

Decisions on annulment actions may be appealed to the Court of Cassation under the HMK; review is limited to the annulment grounds. Parties whose domicile or habitual residence is outside Turkey may waive the right to bring an annulment action wholly or for specific grounds, by an express statement in the arbitration agreement or by a later written agreement. Once a dismissal of the annulment action becomes final, or the time limit expires, the court of first instance issues a certificate of enforceability (Art. 15(B)).

In domestic arbitration, by contrast, the annulment action must be brought within one month before the regional court of appeal of the seat and, unlike under Law No. 4686, does not automatically stay enforcement; a stay requires security (HMK Art. 439).

How do state courts, arbitration and mediation compare?

CriterionState courtsInternational arbitration (Law 4686)Mediation (Law 6325)
BasisStatute; commercial court (TTK Art. 5)Written arbitration agreement (Art. 4)Mandatory by law (TTK Art. 5/A) or voluntary
Decision-makerState judgeArbitrator(s) chosen by the parties or institutionThe mediator does not decide; the parties settle
LanguageTurkishChosen by the parties (Art. 10(C))Agreed by the parties
DurationCan be lengthy with appealsOne year absent agreement (Art. 10(B)), extendableSix weeks + up to two weeks for commercial claims
ConfidentialityHearings generally publicAchievable through institutional rules and contractConfidential unless agreed otherwise (Art. 4)
RemediesAppeal (istinaf) and cassation (temyiz)Annulment action only (30 days, regional court) + limited cassation reviewNo suit on matters settled (Art. 18(5))
Enforcement in TurkeyJudgmentCertificate of enforceability for domestic-seat awards; exequatur for foreign awardsCommercial settlement signed by lawyers and mediator equals a judgment
Enforcement abroadSubject to reciprocity and local recognition rulesGenerally easier thanks to the New York ConventionVaries by country

The table summarises general rules; specific contract terms and institutional rules may lead to different results.

How are foreign arbitral awards enforced in Turkey?

Turkey ratified the 1958 New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards by Law No. 3731 in 1991, with two reservations: it applies the Convention only to awards made in the territory of another contracting state (reciprocity) and only to disputes arising from legal relationships considered commercial under Turkish law. Article 1(2) of Law No. 5718 on Private International Law and International Civil Procedure (MÖHUK) preserves the provisions of international conventions to which Turkey is a party; for awards within its scope the Convention therefore applies first, with MÖHUK playing a supplementary role.

Under MÖHUK, the procedure is as follows:

  1. Nature of the award: foreign arbitral awards that are final and enforceable, or binding on the parties, may be enforced (Art. 60(1)).
  2. Competent court: the court of first instance agreed in writing by the parties; failing that, the court of the losing party's domicile in Turkey, or its residence, or the place where assets subject to enforcement are located (Art. 60(2)).
  3. Documents: the original or a certified copy of the arbitration agreement or clause; the original or a certified copy of the final and enforceable award; and certified translations of both (Art. 61(1)).
  4. Grounds for refusal: absence of an arbitration agreement, conflict with morality or public policy, non-arbitrability under Turkish law, lack of proper representation, lack of proper notice of the appointment of arbitrators or denial of the opportunity to present one's case, invalidity of the arbitration agreement, appointment or procedure contrary to the parties' agreement, excess of authority, and an award that is not yet binding or has been set aside (Art. 62(1)). The burden of proving most of these grounds lies on the party resisting enforcement (Art. 62(2)).

The enforcement court does not re-examine the merits; it reviews only whether these grounds exist.

Can foreign court judgments be enforced in Turkey?

Yes, but an enforcement (exequatur) decision is required. Foreign judgments in civil matters that are final under the law of the state of origin can only be executed in Turkey after a competent Turkish court grants exequatur (MÖHUK Art. 50). The court of first instance has jurisdiction; if the respondent has no domicile or residence in Turkey, the application may be filed in Ankara, Istanbul or Izmir (Art. 51).

The conditions are listed in MÖHUK Article 54: reciprocity between Turkey and the state of origin (by treaty, statutory provision or de facto practice), the judgment not concerning a matter within the exclusive jurisdiction of Turkish courts, the judgment not being manifestly contrary to public policy, and respect for the right of defence. The reciprocity requirement differs from the rules for arbitral awards, so for contracts with counterparties from countries where reciprocity is uncertain, arbitration is generally regarded as more predictable in terms of enforceability. Recognition is regulated separately (Art. 58, and Art. 63 for arbitral awards).

Is investment treaty arbitration against the state possible?

Turkey has signed bilateral investment treaties with many countries. These treaties typically allow disputes between a foreign investor and the host state to be referred to international arbitration (for example under the ICSID or UNCITRAL rules) after a negotiation period. Which routes are available, the preconditions (waiting periods, local-remedies requirements) and the definition of a protected investment depend on the text of each treaty; the country from which the investment is made therefore also matters when structuring an investment.

Under Law No. 4501, the resolution through international arbitration of disputes with a foreign element arising from public service concession conditions and contracts is likewise subject to Law No. 4686 (Law No. 4686, Art. 1(5)). For damages payable in foreign currency or profit repatriation, see the currency and capital transfers guide. Employment disputes follow separate rules; see Turkish employment law.

Frequently asked questions

Can an arbitration clause be included in contracts with foreign parties in Turkey?

Yes. Article 3(e) of Law No. 4875 provides that investment disputes may be referred to national or international arbitration by agreement of the parties. The arbitration agreement must be in writing; electronic communications such as email are sufficient (Law No. 4686, Art. 4). Disputes over rights in rem in immovable property located in Turkey and disputes not subject to the parties' free disposal are not arbitrable.

Is mandatory mediation required if there is an arbitration clause?

No. Under Article 18/A(18) of Law No. 6325, the rules on mandatory mediation do not apply where an arbitration agreement exists. Without an arbitration clause, applying to a mediator before suing is a mandatory precondition for commercial claims for a sum of money, such as receivables and damages (TTK Art. 5/A); a suit filed without it is dismissed on procedural grounds.

What is the deadline to seek annulment of an international arbitral award rendered in Turkey?

The annulment action must be filed before the competent regional court of appeal within 30 days of notification of the award, or of the decision on correction, interpretation or an additional award (Law No. 4686, Art. 15(A)). Filing automatically stays enforcement. The grounds are exhaustively listed in the Law, and the court does not re-examine the merits of the dispute.

Which documents are needed to enforce a foreign arbitral award in Turkey?

Under MÖHUK Article 61, the petition must attach the original or a certified copy of the arbitration agreement or clause, the original or a certified copy of the award that has become final and enforceable or binding, and duly certified translations of these documents. The application is filed with the court of first instance agreed in writing by the parties or, failing that, of the losing party's domicile.

How are ISTAC awards enforced in Turkey?

ISTAC is an arbitral institution established by Law No. 6570. An award rendered in an ISTAC arbitration seated in Turkey with a foreign element is governed by Law No. 4686: once the 30-day annulment period expires or a dismissal of the annulment action becomes final, a certificate of enforceability is obtained from the court of first instance and the award can be enforced. No exequatur proceedings are needed.

Can a foreign court judgment be enforced directly in Turkey?

No. To execute a foreign judgment in Turkey, an exequatur decision must be obtained from a Turkish court of first instance (MÖHUK Arts. 50-51). The court reviews reciprocity, the exclusive jurisdiction of Turkish courts, public policy and the right of defence (Art. 54). Since a lack of reciprocity may block enforcement, choosing arbitration in the contract can reduce this risk.

Sources

  • International Arbitration Law No. 4686, Arts. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 10, 12, 15, Additional Art. 1 (Official Gazette 5 July 2001, No. 24453; Art. 15 as amended by Law No. 7101)
  • Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 (HMK), Arts. 407, 408, 439
  • Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 (TTK), Arts. 5, 5/A
  • Law No. 6325 on Mediation in Civil Disputes, Arts. 4, 18, 18/A
  • Istanbul Arbitration Centre Law No. 6570, Art. 1 (Official Gazette 29 November 2014)
  • Law No. 5718 on Private International Law and International Civil Procedure (MÖHUK), Arts. 1, 50, 51, 54, 58, 60, 61, 62, 63
  • Foreign Direct Investment Law No. 4875, Art. 3(e)
  • New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (1958), ratified by Law No. 3731
Legal noticeThis page is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Turkish legislation changes frequently; before making any decision, check the current law and have your specific situation reviewed by a qualified lawyer. Questions: [email protected]